Bring Dementia Out of the Shadows of Stigma

Juliet Holt Klinger, Guest Blogger

A gentleman approached me while I was manning a dementia information booth at one of our communities. I will call him “John”, although it is not his real name. He told me he resided in independent living and we chatted about this and that. Then he suddenly said, “My doctor tells me I have a smidge of Alzheimer’s.”

John was in great shape and very articulate about his situation. Indeed, it was one of the few times in my over 25 years of working with this disease that I have encountered anyone who was so aware of his own diagnosis. But as we talked for the next hour about the disease, his apprehensions and his fear of becoming incapacitated, it was clear he was scared. He was also angry, saying, “My physician just told me one minute and the next minute I was in my car driving home.” He couldn’t understand how this bombshell could have been dropped in his lap without any accompanying information or recommendations on what to do next.

I was angry on his behalf, but also frankly surprised that he had even been given his diagnosis at all. The Alzheimer’s Association last year published a fact ( that stunned many. Fewer than 50 percent of all people diagnosed with the disease were actually told by the doctors. Meantime, at least 90 percent of people with cancer of various types are informed of their diagnosis.

There are many theories about why physicians avoid telling their patients about an Alzheimer’s diagnosis. Some say it’s a lack of training; others blame a medical system forcing quick visits that don’t allow enough time to counsel patients. However, most of us working in this field believe it comes from the stigma of Alzheimer’s as robbing people of their competence, even of their personhood.

In fact, John told me that during that appointment, he sensed the diagnosis had instantly changed how the physician perceived him. The doctor seemed to think John was no longer capable of understanding his own medical information. John felt the message was clear; there was no expectation of “life” after the diagnosis—or if there was, the physician couldn’t find the words to speak about it.

June is Alzheimer’s and Brain Awareness Month. John’s situation makes it clear that we must bring dementia out of the shadows of stigma. As a society and as individuals — and this includes physicians — we must start talking openly about the disease. People diagnosed with dementia need information and answers so they can plan and make decisions while they are still able to do so, including about how they wish to live in the future. When they are denied this conversation, it is not the disease that robs them of their rights — it is us.

Juliet Holt Klinger, Senior Director of Dementia Care for Brookdale Senior Living is a gerontologist specializing in person-centered programs for Alzheimer’s disease and related dementias. As a trainer and program designer for close to 30 years, she has developed and operationalized programs for national companies representing both skilled nursing and assisted living levels of dementia care.
Juliet holds a Bachelor’s degree in Social Work and an Aging Studies Certificate from the University of Iowa and a Master’s Degree in Gerontology from the University of Northern Colorado. 
In her role for Brookdale, Juliet currently designs and innovates care pathways and programming for Brookdale’s 560+ dementia care communities. Brookdale’s dementia care solutions span from its newest early-stage dementia care communities to skilled nursing and assisted living levels of care.

Thank you. Your comment has been submitted and is pending approval.

Leave a Comment

You May Also Like

Optimum Life Blog: The Circle of Enriching Lives (and other commentary)

Carol Cummings, BSN, RN October 18, 2016

There is nothing I love more than working to enrich the lives of our seniors. Most of the time I do my work from my office, sometimes referred to (I am quite sure) as an Ivory Tower. But I try to base my decisions on what I know from my past experien... Read more

Optimum Life Blog: How long do you want to live?

Carol Cummings, BSN, RN October 10, 2016

A recent analysis by Dr. Jan Vijg and his team at Albert Einstein College suggests that the upper limit of longevity tops out at around 115 years old. These findings, published in the Journal Nature, are news because in recent years some scientists h... Read more